The National Firearms Act of 1934: Dead or Alive?

Over the past few months, firearms legislation and regulation enforcement have been changed drastically, becoming much more relaxed than any time in recent memory. The next few years, though, will be the true determining factors, as this change comes during a time of great uncertainty in national politics, especially seeing as the recent 2026 midterm elections gave way to a historic shift in the allocation of Congress and makeup of several state governments in favor of the Democratic Party. While this likely signals an end to further deregulation of firearms, the effects caused by the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, and Firearms's (ATF) choice to deregulate, as well as the legislative nullification of much of the National Firearms Act of 1934 (NFA), are unlikely to be reversed in the next two years.

Beginning last year with the changes that the Second Trump Administration brought to the executive branch, the ATF began "a new era of reform," committing to relaxing its policies through "transparency, accountability, and partnership with the firearms industry, gun owners, and the public," a sharp change from the past thirty-or-so years. The ATF's reforms under the 'One Big Beautiful Bill' included non-enforcement of a certain tax-stamp policy, which particularly effected long-standing firearms policy in potent ways. The bill nullified the $200 transfer fee and, most importantly, the associated excessively difficult effort previously required to purchase certain non-destructive and non-machinegun firearms, which has undone much of the regulation imposed by the NFA. In theory, short-barreled rifles (SBRs), short-barreled shotguns (SBSs), suppressors, and certain types of concealable firearms that are known under the law as 'any other weapons' (AOWs)—a classification used for many years as a way to include any firearms that might otherwise be used as a loophole—became much easier to access. In practice, these changes remained blocked from going into effect until a federal judge upheld the provision in August of this year.

As mentioned above, it was not merely the tax that was the effectual part. $200 in the modern day, while definitely not insignificant, is much less of a cost than in the 1930s. Instead, it was the intentionally arduous, complicated, and often arbitrary bureaucratic process that the transfer fee was holding up. When Congress required a fee for every transfer, the ATF was allowed to manage the approval process of taxed transfers in any way it deemed necessary. As a result, while on paper the transfer process took only $200, the pre-August 2026 process involved endless forms, providing fingerprints and photographs, and a full background check—all for the ATF to force you to wait days or even weeks to receive your NFA item, assuming you were even approved. The reason all of this was required was that the ATF needed a 'tax stamp' to prove you had paid the $200, and these processes were made requirements to receive the stamp. The final 'nail in the coffin' for the tax came shortly after the court enforced the new law, with the ATF announcing in an open letter that they would enforce neither the "requirements for individuals to apply and receive ATF approval before making or transferring [SBRs], [SBSs], suppressors, and... [AOWs]," nor "the NFA’s registration, tax-stamp or related requirements" for the aforementioned categories of firearms.

The one threat to this broad deregulation, surprisingly, comes from political opposition—the Democratic Party. For about thirty years now, the topic of firearms regulation has been a key partisan issue, with the Democrats being staunchly for 'gun control' and the Republicans against it. Many of the national calls for firearms regulation have come as a result of a general increase in the number of both mass shootings and the media attention given to them. However, due to splits in party opinion, this 'rule' of 21st-century American politics might be waning.

Although the Democrats have deep control of both the House and Senate by numbers, the Party isn't exactly unified on many previously campaigned issues such as gun control. Mitchell Berman and Bobby Pulido are among some of the newly elected Democrats of swing districts who differ quite substantially from their party on gun control, as both are avid hunters and gun owners themselves. As the winning campaigns of many of the newly elected senators and representatives-elect in flipped districts and states were successful in traditionally Republican strongholds—most likely due to a lack of gun control in the Democratic Party's national platform, as well as local variances—Democrat national leadership is likely going to struggle to find the political willpower to rally around any meaningful gun-control legislation. On the other hand, Democrat leaders Jamie Raskin (the representative poised to chair the House Judiciary Committee) seems to not be too concerned about alienating these representatives, stating that his priority as chair would be "requiring background checks on private gun sales, not just purchases from licensed dealers." This would come as a remarkably divisive legislative push with many from the party in opposition.

Another potential issue for the gun-control advocates within the Democratic Party is where the current political attention is concentrated. Data shows that support for the Democratic Party in this election does not necessarily mean support for greater firearms regulation, as many voters in this election are simply voting for another reason. According to Reuters, "Americans [used] Democrats as a tool to punish Donald Trump," and, more broadly, the Republican Party. The Democrats' wild success on Election Day is not actually indicative of their support, as shown by a collection of polls by Real Clear Polling; the Democratic Party is clearly only viewed positively by a minority of the voting population, a far cry from the numbers shown on election night. The American people from over a year ago were generally worried about the lack of change on economic issues such as cost-of-living and inflation. Moreover, a recent Gallup poll showed that gun policy's importance in elections has dropped by 12 points among registered voters surveyed, down to roughly 45% from 2022's 57%. That same poll also showed that only 40% of Democrats who planned to vote in this election said that gun policy was a "top voting issue" in the midterms, which is a statistic that might mean trouble for any Democrat seeking the passage of extensive gun-control legislation.

We have seen before what focusing on controversial partisan issues like gun violence over more universal ones does to a party's national perception during times of economic hardship. One only has to look back to the election of 2024, where Donald Trump won the first national popular vote for a Republican presidential candidate since 2004, a result largely believed to have come primarily from the Democrats' lack of economic recovery and progress in the eyes of the electorate. Therefore, regardless of the Democratic Party's recent gains in Congress, the changes made by the Second Trump Administration and the 'Big Beautiful Bill' are likely to remain unchanged, at least for the time being, meaning that the NFA, while not entirely dead, will remain merely a shell of its former self in national gun control discourse.

Next
Next

What's Next for Christa Pike?