Adults in the United States are prevented from accessing certain content and expressions they wish to view. One may say that this is unlawful, and it likely never occurs. However, this scenario characterizes the blurry lines in legislatures surrounding sexual content: when an adult desires to access lawful sexual content, they are often asked to verify their age through a procedure that involves providing confidential personal information. Fearing a leak of personal data, many choose to close the page.
Although age verification complies with statutory requirements to protect minors from being exposed to harmful sexual content, it raises constitutionality concerns: verifications discourage access to legal content, thereby impeding adults’ access to lawful expressions, a right protected by the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment. Although adults may still access the content, the sophisticated age verification that requires identity verification discourages adult users.
In 2023, Texas enacted H.B.1181 to address children’s unrestricted access to pornographic content that encourages risky sexual behavior. The law imposes age-verification requirements on all websites where over one-third of their content consists of “sexual content harmful to minors.” Users must be at least 18 years old to pass the verification and must verify their age through legal documentation, including government-issued IDs or transaction data. This legislation helps enforce Texas Penal Code § 43.24(b), which prohibits knowingly selling, advertising, distributing, or exhibiting materials harmful to minors. In Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton, the Supreme Court explained that H.B.1181 is used to address § 43.24(b), which was difficult to enforce on its own.
Plaintiffs in the adult-film industry challenged H.B.1181, claiming that the law violates the Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment. Verification methods that necessitate the disclosure of identity obstruct adults — not incidentally — from viewing content that they have a constitutional right to access. It is important to note that this attempt to protect adults’ access to legal sexual content does not include legally obscene material. In Roth v. United States (1957), the Supreme Court ruled that obscenity is not protected “within the area of protected speech and press.” That said, the Supreme Court upheld Texas’ law in Free Speech Coalition, Inc., ruling that H.B.1181 was an appropriate piece of legislation protecting children. Under intermediate scrutiny — which requires legislation to further important government interests in means substantially related to the interest — the Court concluded that age verification only places an incidental burden on adults, since they can still access the material after verifying their age. H.B.1181 advances an important government interest — protecting minors from sexually violent content — in means adequately tailored to the interest.
On the other hand, the disruption to free speech that age verification creates for adults who want to access sexual content cannot be dismissed. Although the majority in Free Speech Coalition, Inc. ruled that burdens placed upon adults are incidental, whether this is actually the case is widely debated. Justice Kagan’s dissent argued that requiring adults to verify their identity sacrifices their anonymity, creates privacy risks, and impedes lawful access; hence, this is a content-based barrier that directly violates the constitutionally protected freedom of expression.
The Free Speech Clause of the First Amendment states, in part, that: "Congress shall make no law … abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press".
H.B.1181 implicates a violation of the Clause. The French data-protection authority, Commission nationale de l’informatique et des libertés (CNIL), warns that age-verification methods can connect sensitive browsing activity with users’ identity, hence undermining the anonymity of the user and exposing their private information to tracking or disclosure.
As a result, H.B.1181 burdens access to lawful sexual content. Research conducted by David Lang and his colleagues indicates a 51% decrease in searches for a compliant platform (one that follows H.B.1181); searches for a noncompliant platform increased by 48.1%, and for VPN services by 23.6%. This pattern may be explained by fear of privacy loss and preference for convenience. This shift reveals the deterrence that age verification tools impose on users, which obstructs access to lawful sexual content protected by the Free Speech Clause. Therefore, this deterrence of adults’ access urges reconsideration of whether the burden is only incidental and whether the law is adequately tailored to protect minors.
The burden placed on adults who desire to access legal sexual content cannot be dismissed as simply incidental. In fact, privacy concerns have discouraged people from accessing protected legal content, as Lang et al.’s (2026) research shows. Since H.B.1181 mandates age verification for all legal sexual websites, a categorical deterrent is placed on access to sexual content. Hence, it poses a content-based burden — not just age-based — that directly hinders adults’ access to a category of lawful expression.
What this issue demands remains up for debate. Its potential unconstitutionality does not directly render it unlawful; examining its lawfulness requires formal judicial review. Justice Kagan, for instance, dissented in Free Speech Coalition, Inc., arguing that the intermediate scrutiny ruling — that H.B.1181 mainly aims to prohibit minors’ access to sexual content and the burden on adults is incidental — is insufficient. Instead, the content-based deterrence means that the Court should apply strict scrutiny.
Ashcroft v. American Civil Liberties Union (2004), in which the Supreme Court reviewed the Child Online Protection Act (COPA), held that COPA was too restrictive in its goal to regulate harmful content, violating the First Amendment. Before H.B.1181 reached the Supreme Court, the District Court for the Western District of Texas preliminarily enjoined the law, explaining that it is likely subject to strict scrutiny as it is “materially identical” to COPA. On the contrary, the majority in the Fifth Circuit argued that Ashcroft erroneously accepted strict scrutiny, while a rational-basis review is sufficient — a conclusion that the Supreme Court ultimately upheld in Free Speech Coalition, Inc. v. Paxton.
From strict scrutiny to the Fifth Circuit’s rational-basis review and the Supreme Court’s intermediate scrutiny, and to Justice Kagan’s dissenting opinion, the metric by which H.B.1181 should be reviewed has various interpretations. Nevertheless, the categorical burden it places on adults’ access to sexual content, a protected form of expression, is an urgent issue demanding serious review alongside freedom of speech.