In the aftermath of World War II, the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) was formed to protect vulnerable refugee populations worldwide. Through its 1951 Refugee Convention, 1967 Protocol, and Convention Against Torture (CAT), the UNHCR enshrined legal safeguards for refugees into international law, protecting them from widespread expulsion by a host nation [1].
Article 33(1) of the 1951 Convention outlines the principle of non-refoulement, which prohibits party states from sending or returning a refugee to territories wherein that individual risks persecution as a result of one’s “race, religion, nationality, membership of a particular social group, or political opinion” [2]. The U.S., beyond being a party to the convention’s 1967 protocol, incorporated non-refoulement into domestic law through the Refugee Act of 1980, which mandates that the U.S. government may not return or deport an individual to a country if they are to face the aforementioned dangers outlined in Article 33(1) of the 1951 convention [3]. Section 241(b)(3) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) creates “withholding of removal,” or the official status given to individuals whose removal would violate non-refoulement. Withholding of removal differs from asylum because it requires a higher burden of proof concerning persecution than the well-founded fear standard applicable to asylum. It also does not itself provide a path to lawful permanent residency. Unlike asylum, withholding of removal is not discretionary and must be granted to all applicants, except in extreme cases outlined in Section203(d)(2), such as individuals who pose a national security threat. Crucially, this law protects refugees from deportation not only from their countries of origin, but also from other countries where they would face persecution on similar grounds [4].
To determine who qualifies for withholding of removal, the Supreme Court established in INS v. Stevic (1984) the “more likely than not” standard [5]. If the applicant can prove that they would more likely than not face persecution in their country of destination, they have a right to protection under U.S. and international law. This differs from the standard for asylum established by INS v. Cardoza-Fonseca (1987) [6]. In this case, the Supreme Court found that applicants must have a “well-founded fear” of persecution, which both legal experts and government officials have understood to be as low as a one-in-ten risk, to qualify for asylum [7]. As such, withholding of removal is harder to prove but is not discretionary.
The Trump administration has aimed to bypass non-refoulement jurisdiction by deporting individuals to supposedly safe external countries, a mechanism outlined in 8 CFR § 208.16(f) [8]. Crucially, third-country removals are not inherently illegal or in violation of non-refoulement. This paper argues, however, that the third-country removals implemented under the Trump Administration violate the standard in INS v. Stevic (1984) because of their lack of due process. To restore the authority of the judiciary in determining who qualifies for withholding of removal, the Supreme Court should issue an injunction prohibiting the Trump Administration from any further removals and demand the return and reevaluation of all individuals who were denied due process in their deportation proceedings.
Over the last year, the Department of Homeland Security under the Trump Administration has deported over 23,000 individuals to countries with which they have no ties or affiliation. The U.S. has signed approximately 35 diplomatic agreements with other countries to accept these individuals [9]. The Trump administration has claimed that these diplomatic agreements ensure that the deported individuals will not be persecuted or tortured. Many of these states conduct similar persecution of specific populations.
Immigration Equality tells the story of Michael, an asylum seeker from Ghana who was fleeing sexuality-based persecution, only to be deported by the U.S. to Equatorial Guinea, where LGBTQ individuals face widespread targeted violence and torture. Michael had been granted withholding of removal to Ghana by an immigration judge, as LGBTQ+ identity comes under the “membership of a particular social group” class in the 1951 convention. However, the federal government then deported him to Equatorial Guinea without his knowledge or any court hearing. Like Ghana, Equatorial Guinea is an African country where LGBTQ individuals face high levels of violence and torture. After one month in Equatorial Guinea, local officials forcibly deported him to Ghana. Because he never had a trial before his deportation to Equatorial Guinea, Michael never had the opportunity to prove he met the “more likely than not” standard set by INS v. Stevic (1984) to protect him from deportation. Michael, in this way, was denied due process [10]. The reasoning underlying this argument has been upheld by the U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy, who ordered the return of a Guatemalan man after he was deported to Mexico, where he was at risk of sexuality-based persecution. The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) argued that because the individual was granted a withholding of removal only in terms of his deportation to Guatemala, the federal government had the right to deport him to Mexico. Judge Murphy struck down this argument, finding that the Guatemalan man being deported to Mexico without a hearing was in violation of due process [11].
Moreover, Michael’s return to Ghana qualifies as chain refoulement [12]. Article 33 of the 1951 Convention clearly states that countries may not return a refugee to potential persecution in his/her home country “in any manner whatsoever” [13]. As such, countries have an obligation to ensure their policies, directly or indirectly, don’t have the effect of returning individuals to their home country in which they are at risk of persecution, which is precisely what happened to Michael. Though the Trump administration has the right under the INA to deport individuals to external countries, its third-country deportations in practice violate Article 33.
In a recent ruling, the Supreme Court granted an emergency request by the Trump administration to block the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals’ hold on third-country removals. This unfortunate decision may allow the administration to continue violating non-refoulement until the Court hears oral arguments in December [14]. Misapplying 8 CFR § 208.16(f), the Trump administration has defied U.S. and international law. Considering that the INS v. Stevic tests set a very specific standard for who qualifies for “withholding of removal,” the Trump administration’s of due process in several instances of the third-country removals is in violation of this precedent. The executive branch’s active effort to bypass judicial holdings raises the law.
If the prohibition of due process becomes a common method to violate the spirit of a judicial holding, as is in the case with the Trump administration's third-country deportations, a concerning divergence could emerge between how the law is practiced and how it is executed. Other cases like INS v. Cardoza-Fonseca (1987) and United States v. Wong Kim Ark (1898), already targets of the Trump administration's anti-immigration policies, could be violated in a fashion similar to INS v. Stevic (1984). Beyond the scope of immigration, the executive precedent the Trump administration has set with the third-country removals may undermine the strength of other cases where due process is a fundamental part of the ruling's application.
Until the countries participating in the third-country removal program can be objectively tested to not present persecutory concerns and due process can be reinstated so that all qualifying applicants under Section 241(b)(3) of the INA have the opportunity to prove a fear of well-founded persecution under the “more likely than not” test for their home countries and external countries to which they may be deported, third-country removals should not continue. To alleviate the legal ramifications the practice has caused thus far, the Supreme Court should reverse its approval of the Trump administration’s emergency request, issue an injunction for the Trump administration from any further removals, and, following U.S. District Judge Brian Murphy, order the return of individuals who were denied due process in their deportation proceedings.
REFERENCES
[1] UN Network on Migration, "The Principle of Non-Refoulement under International Human Rights Law," accessed October 14, 2025, https://migrationnetwork.un.org/resources/principle-non-refoulement-under-international-human-rights-law.
[2] UNHCR, 1951 Refugee Convention and 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees, art. 33(1), accessed October 14, 2025, https://www.unhcr.org/media/1951-refugee-convention-and-1967-protocol-relating-status-refugees.
[3] Refugee Act of 1980, Pub. L. No. 96-212, 94 Stat. 102 (1980), https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/STATUTE-94/pdf/STATUTE-94-Pg102.pdf.
[4] Lehigh Valley Immigration Lawyers, "Withholding of Removal: What It Is and Who Qualifies,” accessed October 14, 2025, https://www.lehighvalleyimmigrationlawyers.com/blog/withholding-of-removal-what-it-is-who-qualifies.
[5] INS v. Stevic, 467 U.S. 407 (1984), https://supreme.justia.com/cases/federal/us/467/407/.
[6] American Immigration Council, "The Difference between Asylum and Withholding of Removal" (Washington, DC: American Immigration Council), accessed October 14, 2025, https://www.americanimmigrationcouncil.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/the_difference_between_asylum_and_withholding_of_removal.pdf.
[7] Immigration Equality, "Immigration Basics: Withholding of Removal," in Asylum Manual, accessed October 14, 2025, https://immigrationequality.org/asylum/asylum-manual/immigration-basics-withholding-of-removal/.
[8] 8 C.F.R. § 208.16(f), Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School, accessed October 14, 2025, https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/8/208.16.
[9] Mark Mengonfia, "US carries out its first deportations under pact for Liberia to accept 1,200 non-Liberians," AP News, accessed October 14, 2025, https://apnews.com/article/liberia-us-deportees-318ab0f9ad74ada4fcd2dff8653c342e.
[10] Immigration Equality, "Protected by U.S. Courts, Deported into Danger: New Immigration Equality Report Exposes Danger to LGBTQ Immigrants under Trump Administration," press release, accessed October 14, 2025, https://immigrationequality.org/press/press-releases-2/protected-by-u-s-courts-deported-into-danger-new-immigration-equality-report-exposes-danger-to-lgbtq-immigrants-under-trump-administration/.
[11] "Judge Orders the Trump Administration to Return a Guatemalan Man to the U.S.," NPR, May 24, 2025, https://www.npr.org/2025/05/24/g-s1-68855/judge-orders-the-trump-administration-to-return-a-guatemalan-man-to-the-u-s.
[12] Immigration Equality, "Protected by U.S. Courts."
[13] UNHCR, 1951 Refugee Convention, art. 33.
[14] Graeme Sloan, "Supreme Court allows Trump’s ‘third country’ deportation policy," NBC News, accessed October 14, 2025, https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/supreme-court/supreme-court-allows-trumps-third-country-deportation-policy-rcna599724.