“Cass Sunstein is one of the most wide-ranging, original, prolific and influential scholars of our time. His work has redefined several academic fields, and the practical applications of his research have had far-reaching impact on public policy.” So begins the Committee Citation awarding him the 2018 Holberg Prize, which is sometimes described as the “equivalent of the Nobel Prize for law and the humanities.” Sunstein, a legal scholar, is the Robert Walmsley University Professor at Harvard. He is a leading voice in U.S. constitutional law, administrative law, and behavioral economics, and is at the top of lists of most-cited legal scholars. Between 2009 to 2012, he was Administrator of the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA). Sunstein has authored hundreds of articles and dozens of books, including Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness (co-authored with Richard Thaler), which has sold more than two million copies since its publication in 2008.
This interview was conducted in Fall 2026. It has been lightly edited for length and clarity.
Daniel Pesin (DP): I’d like to begin by asking about your family background. I’ve learned that you are a descendant of the Vilna Gaon, the hugely influential eighteenth-century Talmudist and legal scholar. Is that something you were aware of growing up? To what extent are you interested in, or proud, of that connection? Do you see any parallels between your work and his?
Cass Sunstein (CS): My aunt mentioned this to me when I was little, but my parents thought it was a ridiculous thing to think about, and I did not think about it. I am not proud of being right-handed or of having an especially small little toe, because I did not do anything to become right-handed or to have that little toe, and I am certainly not proud of my ancestors, because I did not do anything to get them (though I guess he was pretty amazing). I don’t know enough about his work to see parallels; I tend to think, from what little I know, that there aren’t any. He seemed pretty serious? I try to have a bit more fun. But maybe I’m wrong about him.
DP: While at Harvard as an undergraduate, you played squash and were on the board of editors of the Lampoon. What brought you most joy as a Harvard student?
CS: The people on the Lampoon were funnier, but their backhands weren’t so good. I liked both a lot, but I liked squash best. We were national champions, and it was a thrill to get to play on the team, with a legendary coach, Jack Barnaby, and a legendary coach-to-be, Dave Fish, and a great bunch of guys. They were phenomenal.
DP: Having completed your studies at Harvard College and Harvard Law School, you clerked for Justice Benjamin Kaplan of the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court and Justice Thurgood Marshall of the U.S. Supreme Court. In a previous interview with the HULR four years ago, you shared stories about your time with Justice Marshall. How different were these two clerkships from each other, and what are the biggest lessons you learned from them?
CS: Very different. The Supreme Court has far more important cases, of course. Kaplan was a very careful judge, and I learned, I guess, to obsess over details from him. He thought that the trial record was everything. Marshall was focused on the human realities behind the cases, and that is what I learned from him. He constantly asked: What is really going on in this case? What about the people behind the words?
DP: You then spent a year as an attorney-advisor in the U.S. Department of Justice's Office of Legal Counsel. What did your work focus on, and what inroads did you make?
CS: We focused on two kinds of questions: those asked by the President; those involving conflicts within the executive branch. I tried to answer those questions as best I could. For example, can the President ban abortion? Can he require agencies to do cost-benefit analysis? Can he fire the air traffic controllers? What does the 25th Amendment really mean? (Yes, that last one was one of my issues.)
DP: A long period at the University of Chicago followed. This interview takes place just days after the passing of the scholar and judge Richard Posner, whom you knew at Chicago and included in a 2025 list of “Some Personal GOATS.” You have written about Posner’s crucial role in the economic analysis of law; he also taught you to focus on the consequences of law and legal reform. Beyond this, what would you say Posner’s impact on you was? Would you be willing to share any stories from your interactions with him – what was he like?
CS: He had a huge impact on me. Like Marshall, but with the tools of economics, he focused intensely on the consequences of legal rules. You adopt a rent control law. What are its effects? You adopt a maximum hour law. What does that actually do? You move from negligence to strict liability in tort. How are people affected by that? You expand the reach of antitrust law. What does that do for, or to, consumers? Posner always asked that kind of question. He got all of us to ask that kind of question.
Here’s a little story. Ronald Dworkin, also one of the greats, had many disagreements with Dick. He wrote a paper attacking Dick and me simultaneously – Dick for his pragmatism, as I recall, and me for favoring what I called “incompletely theorized agreements.” He called us a kind of Chicago School, and he thought that we were full of nonsense. Dick and I had lunch, and we agreed to coauthor a response. This was on a Friday. I thought I had a sense of how to do a draft, and I wanted first-mover advantage. So I worked really hard over the weekend and managed to produce a full text (without footnotes) by Monday morning. It was about 20 single-spaced pages – rough, but a draft.
When I arrived in my office, I noticed something on my chair. It was a draft from Dick. It was about 30 single-spaced pages, fully footnoted – not rough at all. I was fast, but Dick was the fastest gun in the West.
DP: A lot of your work, such as your 2008 book Nudge: Improving Decisions about Health, Wealth, and Happiness (which you co-wrote with Richard Thaler), has been on the topic of behavioral economics. What implications does an understanding of human irrationality have for regulation and judicial rulings, as opposed to private libertarian paternalism?
CS: Well, I have written maybe 10 books on that topic! Very briefly: We don’t speak of “human irrationality”; that is inaccurate and not very nice. We speak of “bounded rationality.” Nudge is in large part about what governments should do. Take a look at your car, which has a bunch of nudges, some required by law. For example, that camera on the dashboard, which nudges you to look behind. That requirement was issued on my watch.
DP: Are there problems resulting from this intersection between law and behavioral economics that we should prioritize solving? If so, how would you suggest approaching them?
CS: I would prioritize domains where solutions could improve human lives, for example by lengthening them. Road safety is a good area. So is medication adherence, that is, helping people to take the medicines that they have been prescribed. There is a ton to do to improve human health.
DP: I enjoyed your recent talk at Harvard, where you discussed the relevance of Friedrich Hayek in our time. How do you think Hayek would have responded to Nudge and modern behavioral economics, as well as your other work?
CS: I think he would have been skeptical. My new monograph, Hayek for Our Time, discusses this in detail. I don’t think he would have had much trust in government nudging. He might have accepted the central findings of behavioral economics, but he probably would not have wanted the government to use them much. (Professor Hayek, I love you dearly, but here we are just going to have to disagree.)
DP: Something I find interesting about your career is your ability to go back and revise prior beliefs or positions. In an article titled The Statements I Most Regret, you note that you no longer agree with Nudge’s argument that “Marriage, as such, should be completely privatized.” I’m curious as to why you changed your mind on this – did the reversal suggest that you became less libertarian, or that you are less libertarian than Thaler?
CS: Well, I think, on reflection, that state-sponsored marriage is a good idea. It gives people a legal status from which they benefit. That’s basically it.
DP: I’m also curious about the extent to which political developments influence your legal perspective. In the 2006 article Beyond Marbury: The Executive’s Power to Say What the Law is, you argue that “There is no reason to believe that in the face of statutory ambiguity, the meaning of federal law should be settled by the inclinations and predispositions of federal judges. The outcome should instead depend on the commitments and beliefs of the President and those who operate under him.” In the two decades since writing that, have you changed your mind at all, or is that a belief you still hold?
CS: I still hold it. Note that we are speaking of cases in which statutes really are ambiguous. It could mean X, and it could as easily mean Y. Shouldn’t policymakers, rather than judges, get to choose? And if the executive’s interpretation is arbitrary, it’s unlawful. The statement is maybe less inflammatory than it might seem.
DP: Can you map how your views on judicial minimalism have developed over time? What is your position on it today?
CS: I would need to write another book on that one to find out! Basically I agree with One Case at a Time, which I wrote a long time ago. I like the idea of sticking closely to the issue actually before the court, at least in general. I like the idea of narrow, humble rulings. There’s too much that judges do not know.
DP: In the previous interview with the HULR which I mentioned earlier, you spoke about your most significant accomplishments at the Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs (OIRA), which you were the administrator of between 2009 and 2012. I don’t want to ask that same question again, but I am interested in the idea of red tape in politics. In May 2012, while still at OIRA, you wrote a Wall Street Journal article titled “The White House vs. Red Tape.” While working in government, how did you evaluate the state of contemporary red tape, and what was your decision-making process in taking steps as a result?
CS: The US government imposes billions of hours in paperwork burdens. We aimed to cut those numbers – both from 2009-2012, and when I worked at the Department of Homeland Security from 2021-2024, in that period as well. My book Sludge goes into this in detail. We had significant successes but it was, and remains, a mere start. If you like Global Entry and TSA Pre, you’ll see what I have in mind by “successes.” (I was lucky enough to be part of the team that helped create and then improve those programs.)
DP: To follow on from that, when prospective politicians talk about cutting or slashing red tape, what is your response: do you see such promises as a red herring and a political tool, a truly promising course of action, or somewhere in between?
CS: A promising course of action. We have seen a great deal of progress in the last 15 years – not nearly enough, but still, a great deal.
DP: How else do you see politics interacting with regulation? Is there an inherent tension between competing objectives in that interaction?
CS: That’s complicated, and it’s the topic of my book, The Cost-Benefit Revolution. I do like cost-benefit analysis, which I do not see as political. Many people disagree with me, but I think a lot of our divisions are really over questions of fact, not values. Of course if you think that abortion is murder, you will have a different regulatory approach from the approach that you will take if you are pro-choice.
DP: You have described AI as an “imperfect oracle,” distinguishing between what you believe it can and cannot do. Do you think that AI will ever be able to do things that you currently think are beyond its reach? If yes, what would the implications of that be?
CS: No, I don’t think it will ever be able to do those things. Not ever. It can’t tell, for example, whether two people on a date will click, and it can’t tell whether a movie is going to be a big hit. (You’ll have to read Imperfect Oracle to see why.)
DP: Of all of the environments, academic and professional alike, that you have studied and worked in, which have you found most intellectually stimulating?
CS: The White House was the most exciting, I guess, just because of the issues and the stakes. Walking into the building every day was pretty thrilling, and the issues certainly were stimulating. In the 1980s and 1990s, the University of Chicago was electric; the place was on a kind of intellectual fire. Harvard is pretty amazing right now, with people working on different issues (constitutional interpretation, regulation, AI, social media).
DP: Your career has taken you in different directions. Both looking back and looking forwards, do you feel that you have had, or have, a mission?
CS: I try to work on interesting things every day, and if I have an idea that might be a good one, I try to work it through. That’s my little mission, I guess. As Bob Dylan sang: “He been around the world and back again / Something in the moonlight still hounds him.”
DP: How do you hope that your work will influence, and continue to influence, the world? How would you like to be remembered?
CS: “You never count your money / When you’re sittin’ at the table / There’ll be time enough for countin’ / When the dealin’s done.” Didn’t Kenny Rogers say that?